金声玉亮2.0模型评测报告

问题

The following are the beginning sentences of a news article from the Guardian.
-------
Ten of the 12 water companies in the UK have admitted they are still using the practice of water dowsing despite the lack of scientific evidence for its effectiveness. The disclosure has prompted calls for the regulator to stop companies passing the cost of a discredited medieval practice on to their customers. Ofwat said any firm failing to meet its commitments to customers faced a financial penalty. Dowsers, or water witchers, claim that their divining rods cross over when the presence of water is detected below ground. It is regarded as a pseudoscience, after numerous studies showed it was no better than chance at finding water. Some water companies, however, insisted the practice could be as effective as modern methods. The discovery that firms were still using water diviners was made by the science blogger Sally Le Page, after her parents reported seeing an engineer from Severn Trent “walking around holding two bent tent pegs to locate a pipe” near their home in Stratford-upon-Avon. Le Page asked Severn Trent why it was still using divining rods to find pipes when there was no evidence that it worked. Replying on Twitter, the company said: “We’ve found that some of the older methods are just as effective than the new ones, but we do use drones as well, and now satellites.” Le Page then asked the other 11 water companies whether they were using water dowsing. Only one, Wessex Water, said it did not use divining rods, and one, Northern Ireland Water had yet to reply.
-------
Please explain in simpler terms what this text means. At the end of your response, please explicitly add a postscript starting with P.S.

答案

模型	模型答案	正确答案
金声玉亮2.0	The news article from The Guardian talks about a surprising situation in the UK where most water companies, ten out of twelve, are still using an old and unscientific method called water dowsing to find underground water pipes. Water dowsing involves using a divining rod, a simple tool that dowsers believe will point to water when they walk over it. However, science has shown that this method doesn't work any better than guessing where the water might be. This practice is controversial because it's considered a pseudoscience—meaning it's not based on real scientific evidence—and some people are upset that they're paying for something that doesn't have proven effectiveness. The water regulator, Ofwat, has the power to fine companies if they don't keep their promises to customers, which could include using reliable methods. Despite this, some water companies argue that dowsing can be just as good as modern techniques. The issue came to light when a science blogger named Sally Le Page saw an engineer from Severn Trent, one of the water companies, using dowsing rods near her parents' home in Stratford-upon-Avon. She asked Severn Trent why they were using this method, and they replied that they find older methods can work as well as new ones, though they also use drones and satellites. Le Page then asked the other water companies if they use water dowsing. Only Wessex Water said they don't use dowsing rods, while Northern Ireland Water didn't respond to her query. P.S. In simpler terms, the story is about how many UK water companies are still using an old, unproven method to find water pipes, which has raised concerns among customers and regulators about the effectiveness and cost of this practice.	['detectable_content:postscript']
deepseek-r1	This article says that most UK water companies still use a old method called "water dowsing" to find underground water or pipes. This involves holding bent rods (like tent pegs) that supposedly move when water is nearby. Scientists say this doesn’t actually work—it’s just random luck—and call it a fake science. But some companies claim it’s as good as modern tools like drones or satellites. A blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw a worker from Severn Trent using the rods. When she asked the company why they use this method, they defended it. She then asked all 12 UK water companies if they do the same. Ten admitted they do, one said no, and one didn’t answer. People are upset because customers might be paying for this outdated, unproven method, and they want regulators to stop companies from charging for it. P.S. This is about companies using a "magic trick" to find water, even though science says it’s nonsense—and customers might be footing the bill.	['detectable_content:postscript']
gpto1	In simple terms: Most water companies in the UK are still using an old-fashioned method called water dowsing to find underground water. This involves using rods or sticks (sometimes called divining rods or water witching) that supposedly move when they're over water. However, scientists have found no evidence that this method actually works—it performs no better than random chance and is considered a pseudoscience. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this when her parents saw an engineer from the water company Severn Trent using two bent tent pegs to locate a pipe near their home. Curious, she asked the company why they were using this outdated method. The company responded that sometimes old methods are just as effective as new technology, though they also use modern tools like drones and satellites. Wanting to know more, Sally asked all the main water companies in the UK if they also used water dowsing. Ten out of twelve admitted they did. Only one company, Wessex Water, said it did not use divining rods, and one company didn't reply. This has led to people calling for the water regulator, Ofwat, to stop companies from charging customers for a discredited practice. Ofwat stated that companies not meeting customer commitments could face financial penalties. P.S. This article highlights that most UK water companies are still relying on an unproven, medieval technique to find water, and there's growing pressure for them to stop using it in favor of scientifically proven methods.	['detectable_content:postscript']
gpt-4o-2024-08-06	The article talks about how most water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water underground. This method involves using rods that supposedly move when they detect water, but there's no scientific proof that it actually works. People are concerned because these companies might be charging customers for using this outdated and unreliable method. The regulator, Ofwat, has warned that companies not meeting their promises to customers could face fines. A science blogger named Sally Le Page discovered this when her parents saw a water company worker using bent tent pegs to find a pipe. She asked the company, Severn Trent, why they were using this method when it doesn't work. The company replied that they find some old methods as effective as new ones, but they also use modern technology like drones and satellites. Le Page then asked other water companies if they used dowsing. Only Wessex Water said they didn't, and Northern Ireland Water hadn't responded yet. P.S. The article highlights the debate over using traditional methods versus modern technology in finding water, and the importance of using scientifically proven techniques.	['detectable_content:postscript']
DeepSeek-Coder-V2-Lite-Instruct	This news article is about how ten out of the twelve water companies in the UK are still using a practice called water dowsing, which is like trying to find water using two bent tent pegs. This practice is not based on science and has been proven not to be better than just guessing. Some water companies think it can be as good as modern ways to find water, but others don't use this practice. The person who wrote the article, Sally Le Page, asked other water companies if they also use this practice, and some said they don't, but some haven't answered yet. P.S. The practice of water dowsing is considered a pseudoscience because it lacks scientific evidence and is based on old beliefs rather than modern knowledge.	['detectable_content:postscript']
Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo	Here's a simplified explanation of the text: Most water companies in the UK are still using a method called "water dowsing" to find underground water pipes. This method involves using special rods that are supposed to cross over when they detect water. However, many scientists have tested this method and found that it doesn't actually work any better than just guessing. Despite this, the water companies are still using it and passing the cost on to their customers. A science blogger discovered that the companies were still using this method and asked them why. Most of the companies admitted to using it, with one company saying that it's just as effective as modern methods. P.S. It's surprising that many water companies in the UK are still relying on a method that has been discredited by science, and it's good that someone is holding them accountable for it!	['detectable_content:postscript']
Meta-Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct-Turbo	Here's a simpler explanation of the text: Some water companies in the UK are still using an old method called "water dowsing" to find underground water pipes. This method involves using special sticks or rods that are supposed to move when they detect water. However, many scientists don't think this method works and consider it to be a form of superstition. Despite this, 10 out of 12 water companies in the UK admit to still using this method. This has caused some people to complain that the companies are wasting customers' money on a method that doesn't work. The companies are supposed to use more modern and effective methods to find water pipes, and if they don't, they might face fines. P.S. It's interesting to note that the discovery of water companies using water dowsing was made by a science blogger who was curious about why an engineer was using what looked like bent tent pegs to locate a pipe near her parents' home!	['detectable_content:postscript']
Qwen2-72B-Instruct	In the UK, ten out of twelve water companies have admitted that they still use water dowsing, a medieval practice where people use divining rods to find water underground. This is surprising because there is no scientific proof that it works. Some people are asking the regulator, Ofwat, to stop these companies from charging their customers for using this old and unproven method. Ofwat has said that if any company doesn't keep their promises to their customers, they might have to pay a fine. Water dowsers believe that their rods cross when they find water, but studies have shown that this method is no better than guessing. Some water companies, however, think that this old way can work just as well as modern methods. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out that water companies were still using dowsers when her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent using bent tent pegs to look for a pipe near their home. She asked Severn Trent why they were using divining rods when there was no proof that it worked. The company replied that they found that some old methods work just as well as new ones, but they also use drones and satellites. Sally Le Page then asked the other eleven water companies if they were using water dowsing. Only one company, Wessex Water, said they did not use divining rods, and one company, Northern Ireland Water, did not answer. P.S. This means that some water companies in the UK are still using an old and unproven method to find water underground, despite the availability of modern technology.	['detectable_content:postscript']
baichuan4	This text is about how some water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water, even though science says it doesn't work. Water dowsing is when people use sticks or rods to try to find water underground, but studies show it's not accurate. The article says that 10 out of 12 water companies admit to using this method. People are upset because these companies might charge customers for using water dowsing, which is seen as a waste of money. The water regulator, Ofwat, says that if companies don't follow their promises to customers, they could face a fine. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw an engineer using water dowsing. She asked the water companies why they still use this method, and most of them said it works as well as newer methods. However, one company, Wessex Water, said they don't use water dowsing. P.S. This issue shows how some traditional practices can continue even when science says they're not effective, and it raises questions about how companies spend money and what they charge customers for.	['detectable_content:postscript']
doubao	In the UK, 10 out of 12 water companies have admitted they still use water dowsing even though there's no scientific proof it works. This has led to calls for the regulator to make them stop passing the cost of this discredited old practice to customers. Ofwat said any company not meeting its commitments to customers would face a financial penalty. People who do water dowsing claim their rods cross when there's water underground, but it's considered a fake science because many studies showed it's not any better than chance at finding water. Some water companies insisted it could be as effective as modern methods. The fact that companies were still using water diviners was discovered by blogger Sally Le Page after her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent using bent tent pegs to find a pipe near their home. She asked Severn Trent why they still used it when there's no evidence it works. The company replied on Twitter that they think some older methods are as effective as new ones and they also use drones and now satellites. Then Le Page asked the other 11 water companies if they used water dowsing. Only one, Wessex Water, said it didn't, and one, Northern Ireland Water, didn't reply yet. P.S.	['detectable_content:postscript']
gpto1	In simple terms: Most water companies in the UK are still using an old-fashioned method called water dowsing to find underground water. This involves using rods or sticks (sometimes called divining rods or water witching) that supposedly move when they're over water. However, scientists have found no evidence that this method actually works—it performs no better than random chance and is considered a pseudoscience. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this when her parents saw an engineer from the water company Severn Trent using two bent tent pegs to locate a pipe near their home. Curious, she asked the company why they were using this outdated method. The company responded that sometimes old methods are just as effective as new technology, though they also use modern tools like drones and satellites. Wanting to know more, Sally asked all the main water companies in the UK if they also used water dowsing. Ten out of twelve admitted they did. Only one company, Wessex Water, said it did not use divining rods, and one company didn't reply. This has led to people calling for the water regulator, Ofwat, to stop companies from charging customers for a discredited practice. Ofwat stated that companies not meeting customer commitments could face financial penalties. P.S. This article highlights that most UK water companies are still relying on an unproven, medieval technique to find water, and there's growing pressure for them to stop using it in favor of scientifically proven methods.	['detectable_content:postscript']
kimi	This news article is about how 10 out of 12 water companies in the UK are still using a method called water dowsing to find water. Water dowsing is an old technique where people use special sticks to find water underground, but there is no scientific proof that it works. Some people think it's just a trick and not a real science. Even though many studies have shown that water dowsing is not very helpful, some water companies still use it and charge their customers for it. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this and asked the water companies why they were still using this old method. Most of them said that it can be as helpful as modern methods, but they also use other tools like drones and satellites. Only one company said they don't use water dowsing, and another company hasn't answered yet. P.S. This article is about water companies in the UK using an old method called water dowsing to find water, even though there is no proof that it works. Some people are asking the companies to stop using this method and not charge their customers for it.	['detectable_content:postscript']
minimax	This news article from the Guardian is about how most water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water underground, even though there's no scientific proof that it works. Water dowsing involves using a special stick or rod that is supposed to move or cross over when water is below the ground. Many people consider this method to be like a fake science because studies have shown it's no more accurate than just guessing. However, some water companies believe that this old method can be as good as newer, more scientific methods. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this when her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent, a water company, using dowsing near their home. When Le Page asked Severn Trent why they still used this method, they said that they found it just as effective as new methods and also use modern technology like drones and satellites. Le Page then asked all the other water companies if they used dowsing, and most of them said they did, except for Wessex Water, which said it didn't use dowsing, and Northern Ireland Water, which hadn't replied yet. P.S. The article is highlighting a mix of old and new methods used by water companies and the debate over	['detectable_content:postscript']
wenxinyiyan	This news article from the Guardian is about water companies in the UK using a very old method called water dowsing to find water pipes underground. This method involves using special rods that people believe can sense water below the ground. However, there is no scientific proof that this method actually works, and many studies have shown that it is not reliable.尽管如此，仍有10家英国水务公司承认他们还在使用这种方法，这引发了人们的呼吁，要求监管机构阻止这些公司将这种不可信的中世纪做法的成本转嫁给客户。监管机构Ofwat表示，任何未能履行对客户承诺的公司都将面临经济处罚。 A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw an engineer from one of the water companies using these rods. She asked the company why they were still using this method, and they replied that they found it to be as effective as modern methods, like drones and satellites. When she asked other water companies, most of them said they were also using water dowsing. In simpler terms, this text is about UK water companies using an old and unproven method to find water pipes underground, even though there is no scientific evidence that it works. This has caused some people to be concerned and ask for regulations to stop this practice. P.S. Water dowsing, also known as water divining or water witching, is a controversial practice that has been used for centuries but is not supported by modern scientific evidence.	['detectable_content:postscript']
zhipu	This news article from the Guardian says that most water companies in the UK (10 out of 12) are still using a method called water dowsing to find water underground. Water dowsing involves using sticks or rods that are supposed to move when water is nearby, but science hasn't proven that it really works. Because of this, some people are upset that these companies are charging their customers for a method that isn't scientifically supported. The information came out because a science blogger named Sally Le Page noticed an engineer from a company called Severn Trent using this method near her parents' house. When she asked why they were using it, the company said old methods can be as good as new ones, though they also use modern tools like drones and satellites. Sally then asked other water companies if they used dowsing, and most said yes, except for one that said no and another that hadn't answered yet. P.S. This story highlights how some traditional practices are still in use even though they lack scientific backing, and it raises questions about how companies justify their methods and costs to customers.	['detectable_content:postscript']
deepseek-v3	This news article is about how most water companies in the UK are still using a method called "water dowsing" to find water underground, even though there’s no scientific proof that it works. Water dowsing involves using tools like divining rods (often just bent sticks or metal rods) that some people claim move or cross when they detect water. Scientists say this is just a pseudoscience—it doesn’t work any better than random guessing. The article mentions that a science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw a worker from Severn Trent (a water company) using divining rods to locate a pipe. When she asked the company why they still used this method, they said they thought older methods like dowsing were just as good as modern ones, though they also use advanced tools like drones and satellites. Le Page then asked all the other UK water companies if they used dowsing too. Out of 12 companies, 10 admitted they still use it, one said they don’t, and one didn’t respond. This has led to concerns that water companies might be charging customers for a practice that doesn’t actually work. The regulator, Ofwat, has warned that companies failing to meet their commitments could face fines. P.S. Water dowsing is an old, unproven method, and it’s surprising that so many companies still rely on it despite modern technology being available.	['detectable_content:postscript']

模型

模型答案

正确答案

金声玉亮2.0

The news article from The Guardian talks about a surprising situation in the UK where most water companies, ten out of twelve, are still using an old and unscientific method called water dowsing to find underground water pipes. Water dowsing involves using a divining rod, a simple tool that dowsers believe will point to water when they walk over it. However, science has shown that this method doesn't work any better than guessing where the water might be.

This practice is controversial because it's considered a pseudoscience—meaning it's not based on real scientific evidence—and some people are upset that they're paying for something that doesn't have proven effectiveness. The water regulator, Ofwat, has the power to fine companies if they don't keep their promises to customers, which could include using reliable methods.

Despite this, some water companies argue that dowsing can be just as good as modern techniques. The issue came to light when a science blogger named Sally Le Page saw an engineer from Severn Trent, one of the water companies, using dowsing rods near her parents' home in Stratford-upon-Avon. She asked Severn Trent why they were using this method, and they replied that they find older methods can work as well as new ones, though they also use drones and satellites.

Le Page then asked the other water companies if they use water dowsing. Only Wessex Water said they don't use dowsing rods, while Northern Ireland Water didn't respond to her query.

P.S. In simpler terms, the story is about how many UK water companies are still using an old, unproven method to find water pipes, which has raised concerns among customers and regulators about the effectiveness and cost of this practice.

['detectable_content:postscript']

deepseek-r1

This article says that most UK water companies still use a old method called "water dowsing" to find underground water or pipes. This involves holding bent rods (like tent pegs) that supposedly move when water is nearby. Scientists say this doesn’t actually work—it’s just random luck—and call it a fake science. But some companies claim it’s as good as modern tools like drones or satellites.

A blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw a worker from Severn Trent using the rods. When she asked the company why they use this method, they defended it. She then asked all 12 UK water companies if they do the same. Ten admitted they do, one said no, and one didn’t answer. People are upset because customers might be paying for this outdated, unproven method, and they want regulators to stop companies from charging for it.

P.S. This is about companies using a "magic trick" to find water, even though science says it’s nonsense—and customers might be footing the bill.

['detectable_content:postscript']

gpto1

In simple terms:

Most water companies in the UK are still using an old-fashioned method called water dowsing to find underground water. This involves using rods or sticks (sometimes called divining rods or water witching) that supposedly move when they're over water. However, scientists have found no evidence that this method actually works—it performs no better than random chance and is considered a pseudoscience.

A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this when her parents saw an engineer from the water company Severn Trent using two bent tent pegs to locate a pipe near their home. Curious, she asked the company why they were using this outdated method. The company responded that sometimes old methods are just as effective as new technology, though they also use modern tools like drones and satellites.

Wanting to know more, Sally asked all the main water companies in the UK if they also used water dowsing. Ten out of twelve admitted they did. Only one company, Wessex Water, said it did not use divining rods, and one company didn't reply. This has led to people calling for the water regulator, Ofwat, to stop companies from charging customers for a discredited practice. Ofwat stated that companies not meeting customer commitments could face financial penalties.

P.S. This article highlights that most UK water companies are still relying on an unproven, medieval technique to find water, and there's growing pressure for them to stop using it in favor of scientifically proven methods.

['detectable_content:postscript']

gpt-4o-2024-08-06

The article talks about how most water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water underground. This method involves using rods that supposedly move when they detect water, but there's no scientific proof that it actually works. People are concerned because these companies might be charging customers for using this outdated and unreliable method. The regulator, Ofwat, has warned that companies not meeting their promises to customers could face fines.

A science blogger named Sally Le Page discovered this when her parents saw a water company worker using bent tent pegs to find a pipe. She asked the company, Severn Trent, why they were using this method when it doesn't work. The company replied that they find some old methods as effective as new ones, but they also use modern technology like drones and satellites. Le Page then asked other water companies if they used dowsing. Only Wessex Water said they didn't, and Northern Ireland Water hadn't responded yet.

P.S. The article highlights the debate over using traditional methods versus modern technology in finding water, and the importance of using scientifically proven techniques.

['detectable_content:postscript']

DeepSeek-Coder-V2-Lite-Instruct

This news article is about how ten out of the twelve water companies in the UK are still using a practice called water dowsing, which is like trying to find water using two bent tent pegs. This practice is not based on science and has been proven not to be better than just guessing. Some water companies think it can be as good as modern ways to find water, but others don't use this practice. The person who wrote the article, Sally Le Page, asked other water companies if they also use this practice, and some said they don't, but some haven't answered yet.

P.S. The practice of water dowsing is considered a pseudoscience because it lacks scientific evidence and is based on old beliefs rather than modern knowledge.

['detectable_content:postscript']

Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo

Here's a simplified explanation of the text:

Most water companies in the UK are still using a method called "water dowsing" to find underground water pipes. This method involves using special rods that are supposed to cross over when they detect water. However, many scientists have tested this method and found that it doesn't actually work any better than just guessing. Despite this, the water companies are still using it and passing the cost on to their customers. A science blogger discovered that the companies were still using this method and asked them why. Most of the companies admitted to using it, with one company saying that it's just as effective as modern methods.

P.S. It's surprising that many water companies in the UK are still relying on a method that has been discredited by science, and it's good that someone is holding them accountable for it!

['detectable_content:postscript']

Meta-Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct-Turbo

Here's a simpler explanation of the text:

Some water companies in the UK are still using an old method called "water dowsing" to find underground water pipes. This method involves using special sticks or rods that are supposed to move when they detect water. However, many scientists don't think this method works and consider it to be a form of superstition. Despite this, 10 out of 12 water companies in the UK admit to still using this method. This has caused some people to complain that the companies are wasting customers' money on a method that doesn't work. The companies are supposed to use more modern and effective methods to find water pipes, and if they don't, they might face fines.

P.S. It's interesting to note that the discovery of water companies using water dowsing was made by a science blogger who was curious about why an engineer was using what looked like bent tent pegs to locate a pipe near her parents' home!

['detectable_content:postscript']

Qwen2-72B-Instruct

In the UK, ten out of twelve water companies have admitted that they still use water dowsing, a medieval practice where people use divining rods to find water underground. This is surprising because there is no scientific proof that it works. Some people are asking the regulator, Ofwat, to stop these companies from charging their customers for using this old and unproven method. Ofwat has said that if any company doesn't keep their promises to their customers, they might have to pay a fine. Water dowsers believe that their rods cross when they find water, but studies have shown that this method is no better than guessing. Some water companies, however, think that this old way can work just as well as modern methods. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out that water companies were still using dowsers when her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent using bent tent pegs to look for a pipe near their home. She asked Severn Trent why they were using divining rods when there was no proof that it worked. The company replied that they found that some old methods work just as well as new ones, but they also use drones and satellites. Sally Le Page then asked the other eleven water companies if they were using water dowsing. Only one company, Wessex Water, said they did not use divining rods, and one company, Northern Ireland Water, did not answer.

P.S. This means that some water companies in the UK are still using an old and unproven method to find water underground, despite the availability of modern technology.

['detectable_content:postscript']

baichuan4

This text is about how some water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water, even though science says it doesn't work. Water dowsing is when people use sticks or rods to try to find water underground, but studies show it's not accurate. The article says that 10 out of 12 water companies admit to using this method.

People are upset because these companies might charge customers for using water dowsing, which is seen as a waste of money. The water regulator, Ofwat, says that if companies don't follow their promises to customers, they could face a fine.

A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw an engineer using water dowsing. She asked the water companies why they still use this method, and most of them said it works as well as newer methods. However, one company, Wessex Water, said they don't use water dowsing.

P.S. This issue shows how some traditional practices can continue even when science says they're not effective, and it raises questions about how companies spend money and what they charge customers for.

['detectable_content:postscript']

doubao

In the UK, 10 out of 12 water companies have admitted they still use water dowsing even though there's no scientific proof it works. This has led to calls for the regulator to make them stop passing the cost of this discredited old practice to customers. Ofwat said any company not meeting its commitments to customers would face a financial penalty. People who do water dowsing claim their rods cross when there's water underground, but it's considered a fake science because many studies showed it's not any better than chance at finding water. Some water companies insisted it could be as effective as modern methods. The fact that companies were still using water diviners was discovered by blogger Sally Le Page after her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent using bent tent pegs to find a pipe near their home. She asked Severn Trent why they still used it when there's no evidence it works. The company replied on Twitter that they think some older methods are as effective as new ones and they also use drones and now satellites. Then Le Page asked the other 11 water companies if they used water dowsing. Only one, Wessex Water, said it didn't, and one, Northern Ireland Water, didn't reply yet.

P.S.

['detectable_content:postscript']

gpto1

['detectable_content:postscript']

kimi

This news article is about how 10 out of 12 water companies in the UK are still using a method called water dowsing to find water. Water dowsing is an old technique where people use special sticks to find water underground, but there is no scientific proof that it works. Some people think it's just a trick and not a real science. Even though many studies have shown that water dowsing is not very helpful, some water companies still use it and charge their customers for it. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this and asked the water companies why they were still using this old method. Most of them said that it can be as helpful as modern methods, but they also use other tools like drones and satellites. Only one company said they don't use water dowsing, and another company hasn't answered yet.

P.S. This article is about water companies in the UK using an old method called water dowsing to find water, even though there is no proof that it works. Some people are asking the companies to stop using this method and not charge their customers for it.

['detectable_content:postscript']

minimax

This news article from the Guardian is about how most water companies in the UK are still using an old method called water dowsing to find water underground, even though there's no scientific proof that it works. Water dowsing involves using a special stick or rod that is supposed to move or cross over when water is below the ground. Many people consider this method to be like a fake science because studies have shown it's no more accurate than just guessing. However, some water companies believe that this old method can be as good as newer, more scientific methods. A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this when her parents saw an engineer from Severn Trent, a water company, using dowsing near their home. When Le Page asked Severn Trent why they still used this method, they said that they found it just as effective as new methods and also use modern technology like drones and satellites. Le Page then asked all the other water companies if they used dowsing, and most of them said they did, except for Wessex Water, which said it didn't use dowsing, and Northern Ireland Water, which hadn't replied yet.

P.S. The article is highlighting a mix of old and new methods used by water companies and the debate over

['detectable_content:postscript']

wenxinyiyan

This news article from the Guardian is about water companies in the UK using a very old method called water dowsing to find water pipes underground. This method involves using special rods that people believe can sense water below the ground. However, there is no scientific proof that this method actually works, and many studies have shown that it is not reliable.尽管如此，仍有10家英国水务公司承认他们还在使用这种方法，这引发了人们的呼吁，要求监管机构阻止这些公司将这种不可信的中世纪做法的成本转嫁给客户。监管机构Ofwat表示，任何未能履行对客户承诺的公司都将面临经济处罚。

A science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw an engineer from one of the water companies using these rods. She asked the company why they were still using this method, and they replied that they found it to be as effective as modern methods, like drones and satellites. When she asked other water companies, most of them said they were also using water dowsing.

In simpler terms, this text is about UK water companies using an old and unproven method to find water pipes underground, even though there is no scientific evidence that it works. This has caused some people to be concerned and ask for regulations to stop this practice.

P.S. Water dowsing, also known as water divining or water witching, is a controversial practice that has been used for centuries but is not supported by modern scientific evidence.

['detectable_content:postscript']

zhipu

This news article from the Guardian says that most water companies in the UK (10 out of 12) are still using a method called water dowsing to find water underground. Water dowsing involves using sticks or rods that are supposed to move when water is nearby, but science hasn't proven that it really works. Because of this, some people are upset that these companies are charging their customers for a method that isn't scientifically supported.

The information came out because a science blogger named Sally Le Page noticed an engineer from a company called Severn Trent using this method near her parents' house. When she asked why they were using it, the company said old methods can be as good as new ones, though they also use modern tools like drones and satellites. Sally then asked other water companies if they used dowsing, and most said yes, except for one that said no and another that hadn't answered yet.

P.S. This story highlights how some traditional practices are still in use even though they lack scientific backing, and it raises questions about how companies justify their methods and costs to customers.

['detectable_content:postscript']

deepseek-v3

This news article is about how most water companies in the UK are still using a method called "water dowsing" to find water underground, even though there’s no scientific proof that it works. Water dowsing involves using tools like divining rods (often just bent sticks or metal rods) that some people claim move or cross when they detect water. Scientists say this is just a pseudoscience—it doesn’t work any better than random guessing.

The article mentions that a science blogger named Sally Le Page found out about this after her parents saw a worker from Severn Trent (a water company) using divining rods to locate a pipe. When she asked the company why they still used this method, they said they thought older methods like dowsing were just as good as modern ones, though they also use advanced tools like drones and satellites.

Le Page then asked all the other UK water companies if they used dowsing too. Out of 12 companies, 10 admitted they still use it, one said they don’t, and one didn’t respond. This has led to concerns that water companies might be charging customers for a practice that doesn’t actually work. The regulator, Ofwat, has warned that companies failing to meet their commitments could face fines.

P.S. Water dowsing is an old, unproven method, and it’s surprising that so many companies still rely on it despite modern technology being available.

['detectable_content:postscript']