金声玉亮2.0模型评测报告

问题

The following are the beginning sentences of a news article from the Guardian.
-------
Jeff Stelling is known for being a cheery sort. The most exasperated he ever gets is when Hartlepool are drubbed and, even then, he usually bears it with the fatalism of the long-suffering supporter. This week, however, the Sky Sports presenter has starred in a much-shared clip in which he goes on an actual rant. And the subject? Expected goals. In the run-up to their coverage of the north London derby, Stelling observed to his Soccer Saturday pundits that Arsène Wenger had done a daft thing. “He quoted expected goals!” Stelling said to an audible “No!” from one of his guests (perhaps Phil Thompson). “He’s the first person I’ve ever heard take any notice of expected goals, which must be the most useless stat in the history of football! What does it tell you? The game’s finished 3-1, why do you show expected goals afterwards?” Stelling’s remarks prompted much laughter in the studio and, after Soccer AM took a grab of the video, it got a lot of chuckles online, too.
-------
Please summarize based on the sentences provided. Answer with one of the following options: ('My answer is yes.', 'My answer is no.', 'My answer is maybe.')

答案

模型	模型答案	正确答案
金声玉亮2.0	My answer is maybe. The given sentences describe a situation where Jeff Stelling, a usually cheerful Sky Sports presenter, expressed strong disapproval of the concept of "expected goals" in football analysis. He criticized Arsène Wenger for referencing this statistic, calling it the "most useless stat in the history of football." Stelling's comments were met with laughter in the studio and gained popularity online after being shared by Soccer AM. However, the sentences do not provide enough information to answer a question with a simple yes or no, as they are describing an event rather than posing a question or statement to be agreed or disagreed with.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
deepseek-r1	My answer is yes.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
gpto1	My answer is yes.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
gpt-4o-2024-08-06	My answer is no.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
DeepSeek-Coder-V2-Lite-Instruct	My answer is maybe.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo	It seems like you forgot to include the question to be answered. Please provide the question, and I'll be happy to summarize and respond with one of the options.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
Meta-Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct-Turbo	My answer is no.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
Qwen2-72B-Instruct	My answer is maybe. The given sentences describe a situation where Jeff Stelling, a usually cheerful Sky Sports presenter, expressed strong disapproval of the concept of "expected goals" in football analysis. He was particularly critical of Arsène Wenger for referencing this statistic. Stelling's comments were met with laughter in the studio and gained attention online after being shared by Soccer AM. However, the sentences do not provide enough information to answer a yes or no question, as they are simply recounting an event and do not pose a question or proposition to agree or disagree with.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
baichuan4	'My answer is yes.'	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
doubao	My answer is maybe. The text mainly focuses on Jeff Stelling, known for being cheery but ranting about expected goals this week, with his remarks during Sky Sports coverage of the north London derby, which got a lot of attention and laughter, but it doesn't provide a definite yes or no conclusion.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
gpto1	My answer is yes.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
kimi	My answer is no.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
minimax	My answer is yes.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
wenxinyiyan	My answer is no. Summary: Sky Sports presenter Jeff Stelling has starred in a viral clip in which he rants about the uselessness of expected goals, a statistic he believes to be the most pointless in football history, prompting laughter in the studio and online.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
zhipu	My answer is no. The sentences provided describe Jeff Stelling, a Sky Sports presenter, expressing his frustration about the concept of "expected goals" in football, which he considers the most useless statistic. His rant was shared widely and received laughter both in the studio and online. The summary does not directly ask a question that can be answered with a simple 'yes', 'no', or 'maybe'. Instead, it provides information about Stelling's opinion and the reaction it garnered. Therefore, none of the provided answer options ('My answer is yes.', 'My answer is no.', 'My answer is maybe.') are appropriate as a summary of the given text.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']
deepseek-v3	My answer is maybe.	['detectable_format:constrained_response']

模型

模型答案

正确答案

金声玉亮2.0

My answer is maybe.

The given sentences describe a situation where Jeff Stelling, a usually cheerful Sky Sports presenter, expressed strong disapproval of the concept of "expected goals" in football analysis. He criticized Arsène Wenger for referencing this statistic, calling it the "most useless stat in the history of football." Stelling's comments were met with laughter in the studio and gained popularity online after being shared by Soccer AM. However, the sentences do not provide enough information to answer a question with a simple yes or no, as they are describing an event rather than posing a question or statement to be agreed or disagreed with.