问题

The following are the beginning sentences of a news article from the Guardian.
-------
The Turnbull government has deployed new modelling on the national energy guarantee in an effort to step up pressure on state governments to sign up to its policy at a meeting of energy ministers on Friday. A summary of the modelling, circulated by the government in advance of the talks with the states, suggests household power bills between 2020 and 2030 would be “in the order of” $120 a year lower, in today’s dollars, than under a business-as-usual scenario, if the policy applied across the national electricity market. The material supplied by the government says wholesale electricity prices would be 23% lower than business-as-usual between 2020 and 2030, and it suggests the share of renewables in the market by 2030 “could range from 32% to 36%”. The full modelling, undertaken for the Energy Security Board by Frontier Economics, has not yet been distributed to state energy ministers and the documents circulated in Canberra are a summary of the findings, not the work itself. The Turnbull government announced in October it would dump the clean energy target recommended by the chief scientist, Alan Finkel, and proceed with the national energy guarantee – a policy that imposes new reliability and emissions reduction guarantees on energy retailers and large energy users from 2020. The policy requires cooperation from the states but some of the Labor governments, particularly South Australia, have been hostile. Part of the reason for that is the states were involved in the exhaustive consultations with Finkel about the clean energy target but were not kept in the loop about the national energy guarantee. Some state governments are also concerned the Turnbull policy will hard-bake coal into the system at the expense of renewables at a time when the energy market needs to transition to low-emissions power sources. A spokesman for the South Australian premier, Jay Weatherill, is continuing to insist that the state will not commit to sign on to the national energy guarantee in the absence of data showing its specific impact on the state. The Labor states have also commissioned their own work through the Council of Australian Governments energy council examining whether or not they could implement a clean energy target by themselves.
-------
Please generate a story based on the sentences provided. Answer with less than 267 words. Your answer must contain exactly 5 bullet points. Use the markdown bullet points such as:
* This is point 1.
* This is point 2

答案

模型 模型答案 正确答案
金声玉亮2.0 * The Turnbull government is ramping up pressure on state governments to endorse the national energy guarantee, a policy aimed at ensuring energy reliability and emissions reduction, ahead of a critical meeting of energy ministers.
* According to government-provided summaries, the policy could reduce household power bills by approximately $120 per year between 2020 and 2030, compared to current trends, and lead to a 23% decrease in wholesale electricity prices.
* The share of renewables in the market could grow to between 32% and 36% by 2030 under the national energy guarantee, signaling a significant shift towards green energy sources.
* State governments, particularly those led by the Labor party, have been skeptical, partly due to their exclusion from the policy's development process, which contrasts with their involvement in consultations for the clean energy target proposed by Chief Scientist Alan Finkel.
* South Australia, under Premier Jay Weatherill, remains particularly resistant, demanding data that demonstrates the policy's specific impact on the state before committing to the national energy guarantee.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
deepseek-r1

* The Turnbull government uses new modeling to push states to adopt the National Energy Guarantee (NEG), claiming households could save $120 annually on power bills from 2020–2030 compared to current trends.
* Wholesale electricity prices are projected to drop 23% under the NEG, with renewables estimated to comprise 32%–36% of the energy market by 2030, though states await full modeling details.
* States like South Australia resist the NEG, citing exclusion from policy discussions and fears it prioritizes coal over renewables during a critical transition to low-emission energy.
* South Australia’s government demands state-specific impact data before endorsing the NEG, reflecting broader Labor-state skepticism after being sidelined on the abandoned clean energy target.
* Labor states explore independent clean energy targets via COAG, signaling defiance against federal pressure and a push for renewables amid stalled negotiations.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
gpto1 * The Turnbull government is pressuring state governments to adopt its national energy guarantee policy, leveraging new modeling that suggests significant cost savings for households and lower wholesale electricity prices between 2020 and 2030.
* According to the government's summary, households could save approximately $120 a year on power bills compared to a business-as-usual scenario, and wholesale electricity prices might be reduced by 23% during the same period.
* The modeling also indicates that renewable energy could comprise between 32% to 36% of the national electricity market by 2030, assuming the policy is implemented across the board.
* Some Labor-led state governments, especially South Australia, are hesitant to commit without detailed data specific to their regions, expressing concerns that the policy may favor coal over renewables and hinder the transition to low-emission energy sources.
* In response to the federal government's approach, these states are exploring the possibility of enacting their own clean energy target through the Council of Australian Governments energy council, having previously been involved in consultations for the abandoned clean energy target recommended by chief scientist Alan Finkel.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
gpt-4o-2024-08-06 * The Turnbull government is actively promoting the national energy guarantee (NEG) policy, aiming to secure agreement from state governments during an upcoming energy ministers' meeting. The government has circulated a summary of new modelling to bolster its case, highlighting potential benefits for household power bills and wholesale electricity prices.

* According to the government's summary, if the NEG is implemented across the national electricity market, household power bills could be approximately $120 lower annually between 2020 and 2030 compared to a business-as-usual scenario. Additionally, wholesale electricity prices are projected to be 23% lower during the same period.

* The modelling, conducted by Frontier Economics for the Energy Security Board, also suggests that the share of renewables in the energy market could increase to between 32% and 36% by 2030. However, the full modelling details have not been shared with state energy ministers, with only a summary being circulated in Canberra.

* The Turnbull government decided to abandon the clean energy target proposed by chief scientist Alan Finkel in favor of the NEG, which introduces new reliability and emissions reduction requirements for energy retailers and large users starting in 2020. This shift has faced resistance from some Labor-led states, particularly South Australia, due to concerns about the policy's impact on renewable energy integration.

* South Australia's government, led by Premier Jay Weatherill, remains skeptical and demands specific data on the NEG's impact on the state before committing to the policy. Meanwhile, Labor states are exploring the possibility of implementing a clean energy target independently through the Council of Australian Governments energy council.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
DeepSeek-Coder-V2-Lite-Instruct The Turnbull government has released new modelling on the national energy guarantee, aiming to intensify pressure on state governments to adopt the policy at an upcoming meeting of energy ministers. The modelling, which was circulated ahead of the meeting, indicates that household power bills could be reduced by approximately $120 annually between 2020 and 2030 compared to a business-as-usual scenario. Additionally, wholesale electricity prices are projected to be 23% lower over the same period, and the share of renewables in the market by 2030 could range from 32% to 36%.

* This is point 1.
* This is point 2.
* This is point 3.
* This is point 4.
* This is point 5.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo The Turnbull government is pushing for state governments to sign up to its national energy guarantee policy, releasing new modelling that suggests household power bills could be $120 a year lower by 2030. The policy, announced in October, imposes new reliability and emissions reduction guarantees on energy retailers and large energy users from 2020.

However, some Labor state governments, particularly South Australia, have been hostile to the policy, citing concerns that it will favor coal over renewables and hinder the transition to low-emissions power sources. To address these concerns, the government has released a summary of the modelling, undertaken by Frontier Economics, which suggests:

* Wholesale electricity prices could be 23% lower than business-as-usual between 2020 and 2030.
* The share of renewables in the market by 2030 could range from 32% to 36%.
* Household power bills could be $120 a year lower by 2030.
* The policy requires cooperation from the states, but some are hesitant to sign up without more data on its specific impact.
* The Labor states have commissioned their own work to examine whether they could implement a clean energy target by themselves, potentially bypassing the national energy guarantee.

Despite the government's efforts, South Australia remains unconvinced, with Premier Jay Weatherill's spokesman insisting that the state will not commit to the policy without more data on its specific impact.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
Meta-Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct-Turbo The Australian government, led by Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, is pushing for state governments to sign up to its national energy guarantee policy. The policy aims to reduce household power bills and increase the share of renewables in the market. However, some state governments, particularly those led by Labor, are hesitant to commit.

Here are the key points of the policy and the concerns of the state governments:

* The national energy guarantee policy is expected to lower household power bills by $120 per year between 2020 and 2030, compared to a business-as-usual scenario.
* Wholesale electricity prices are predicted to be 23% lower than business-as-usual between 2020 and 2030.
* The policy aims to increase the share of renewables in the market to between 32% and 36% by 2030.
* However, some state governments are concerned that the policy will favor coal over renewables, hindering the transition to low-emissions power sources.
* The Labor states, including South Australia, are considering implementing their own clean energy target, and have commissioned their own research to examine the feasibility of this option.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
Qwen2-72B-Instruct * The Turnbull government is ramping up pressure on state governments to endorse the national energy guarantee, a policy aimed at ensuring energy reliability and emissions reduction, ahead of a meeting of energy ministers.
* According to government-provided modeling, the policy could result in household power bills being $120 lower annually between 2020 and 2030, compared to current trends, and could see a 23% decrease in wholesale electricity prices.
* The share of renewables in the market by 2030 is projected to be between 32% to 36%, as per the summary of the modeling by Frontier Economics, commissioned by the Energy Security Board.
* The full modeling details have not been shared with state energy ministers, leading to skepticism, especially from Labor-led states like South Australia, which fear the policy may favor coal over renewables.
* South Australia's premier, Jay Weatherill, demands data on the policy's specific impact on his state before committing, while other Labor states explore the possibility of implementing a clean energy target independently.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
baichuan4 * The Turnbull government has unveiled new energy policy modeling, aiming to persuade state governments to adopt the national energy guarantee.
* The modeling indicates potential savings of approximately $120 annually on household power bills from 2020 to 2030, compared to a business-as-usual scenario.
* It also projects a 23% reduction in wholesale electricity prices within the same timeframe and a renewable energy market share ranging from 32% to 36% by 2030.
* Despite these projections, the full modeling details have not been shared with state energy ministers, fueling skepticism among some states, particularly South Australia.
* South Australia's government, along with other Labor states, is hesitant to commit to the policy without detailed data on its specific impacts and is exploring alternative options, including a potential standalone clean energy target.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
doubao * The Turnbull government used new modelling on the national energy guarantee.
* It claims household bills would be lower and wholesale prices reduced by 2020-2030.
* The full modelling by Frontier Economics hasn't been distributed; summaries were circulated.
* The government dumped the clean energy target and proceeded with the guarantee.
* Some states are hostile, concerned about coal and lack of consultation.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
gpto1 * The Turnbull government is pressuring state governments to adopt its national energy guarantee policy, leveraging new modeling that suggests significant cost savings for households and lower wholesale electricity prices between 2020 and 2030.
* According to the government's summary, households could save approximately $120 a year on power bills compared to a business-as-usual scenario, and wholesale electricity prices might be reduced by 23% during the same period.
* The modeling also indicates that renewable energy could comprise between 32% to 36% of the national electricity market by 2030, assuming the policy is implemented across the board.
* Some Labor-led state governments, especially South Australia, are hesitant to commit without detailed data specific to their regions, expressing concerns that the policy may favor coal over renewables and hinder the transition to low-emission energy sources.
* In response to the federal government's approach, these states are exploring the possibility of enacting their own clean energy target through the Council of Australian Governments energy council, having previously been involved in consultations for the abandoned clean energy target recommended by chief scientist Alan Finkel.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
kimi * The Turnbull government is using new modeling on the national energy guarantee to encourage state governments to support its policy at an upcoming meeting. The modeling suggests that household power bills would be $120 lower per year between 2020 and 2030, and wholesale electricity prices would be 23% lower than a business-as-usual scenario.
* The government's modeling also indicates that the share of renewables in the market by 2030 could range from 32% to 36%. However, the full modeling has not yet been distributed to state energy ministers, and the documents circulated are only a summary of the findings.
* The Turnbull government announced in October that it would abandon the clean energy target recommended by the chief scientist, Alan Finkel, in favor of the national energy guarantee. This policy imposes new reliability and emissions reduction guarantees on energy retailers and large energy users from 2020.
* Some Labor governments, particularly South Australia, have been hostile to the national energy guarantee, partly because they were not involved in its development. They are also concerned that the policy will favor coal at the expense of renewables during a time when the energy market needs to transition to low-emissions power sources.
* Labor states have commissioned their own work to examine whether they could implement a clean energy target independently, while a spokesman for South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill insists that the state will not commit to the national energy guarantee without data showing its specific impact on the state.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
minimax * The Turnbull government has introduced new modeling on the national energy guarantee to persuade state governments to support its policy during a meeting of energy ministers.
* The government's summary indicates that household power bills could be $120 a year lower by 2030 compared to a business-as-usual scenario, with wholesale electricity prices 23% lower over the same period.
* The modeling suggests that the share of renewables in the market could range from 32% to 36% by 2030, as detailed in a summary circulated by the government.
* The Turnbull administration has opted for the national energy guarantee over the clean energy target recommended by Alan Finkel, causing some state governments, especially Labor ones, to be skeptical.
* South Australia, under Premier Jay Weatherill, refuses to commit to the national energy guarantee without specific data on its impact on the state, and Labor states are exploring the possibility of implementing a clean energy target independently.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
wenxinyiyan * The Turnbull government introduced new modeling on the national energy guarantee to pressure state governments to adopt the policy.
* The modeling suggests that household power bills would be lower by $120 a year if the policy is implemented nationwide, compared to a business-as-usual scenario.
* The government's material indicates wholesale electricity prices would drop by 23% between 2020 and 2030, and renewables could account for 32% to 36% of the market by 2030.
* Some state governments, particularly South Australia, are hostile to the national energy guarantee, as they were not consulted during its development and fear it will prioritize coal over renewables.
* The Labor states are considering implementing a clean energy target independently, and South Australia demands data showing the specific impact of the national energy guarantee on their state before committing to it.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
zhipu The Turnbull government has unveiled new energy modelling to sway state governments into endorsing its national energy guarantee ahead of a pivotal energy ministers' meeting.

* **Modelling Projections**: The government's summary forecasts household power bills to be approximately $120 lower annually between 2020 and 2030 compared to a business-as-usual scenario, if the policy is universally adopted.
* **Wholesale Price Reduction**: Wholesale electricity prices are expected to drop by 23% over the same period under the guarantee.
* **Renewables Share**: The policy could see renewables' market share reach between 32% and 36% by 2030.
* **Policy Shift and State Skepticism**: Following the rejection of the clean energy target proposed by Chief Scientist Alan Finkel, the national energy guarantee was introduced, imposing new standards on energy retailers and large users from 2020. However, states like South Australia remain opposed, citing lack of consultation and concerns over coal prioritization over renewables.
* **Data Demand and Independent Assessment**: South Australia's Premier Jay Weatherill demands specific impact data for his state before committing. Meanwhile, Labor states are exploring the feasibility of implementing a clean energy target independently through the Council of Australian Governments energy council.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']
deepseek-v3 * The Turnbull government is pushing state governments to adopt the National Energy Guarantee (NEG) at an upcoming energy ministers' meeting.
* New modelling suggests the NEG could lower household power bills by $120 annually and reduce wholesale electricity prices by 23% between 2020 and 2030.
* The policy aims to increase renewables' share in the energy market to 32-36% by 2030, replacing the previously recommended clean energy target.
* Some Labor-led states, particularly South Australia, are resisting the NEG due to concerns it prioritizes coal over renewables and lacks state-specific impact data.
* Labor states are independently exploring the feasibility of implementing their own clean energy targets through the Council of Australian Governments.		 ['length_constraints:number_words' 'detectable_format:number_bullet_lists']